Trump again picks personal lawyer for a top job as US attorney in Manhattan

Maggie Haberman, Benjamin Weiser and Alan Feuer

WASHINGTON – US President Donald Trump said on June 13 that he would nominate James M. McDonald to be the next US attorney in the Southern District of New York (SDNY), again choosing one of his personal lawyers for one of the nation’s most powerful legal positions.

Trump praised McDonald, pointing to his extensive credentials.

He is “a former Assistant US Attorney in the Southern District of New York, and served as Director of Enforcement at the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission during my First Term”, Trump wrote. McDonald was also a law clerk to Chief Justice John Roberts.

McDonald would replace Jay Clayton, Trump’s choice to be the next director of national intelligence after his temporary pick for that role, Bill Pulte – a top federal housing official – set off widespread concerns among Republican senators for his lack of intelligence experience and his zeal in pursuing Trump’s perceived enemies. Clayton still requires Senate confirmation.

McDonald, who goes by Jamie, is a litigation partner at Sullivan & Cromwell, the law firm handling Trump’s appeal of his criminal conviction in a Manhattan state court on 34 felony counts of falsifying business records in connection with concealing a hush-money payment to a porn star during the 2016 presidential campaign.

McDonald is a member of the Trump appeals team for that case.

It was the Southern District of New York, historically one of the most independent federal prosecutor offices in the country, that paved the way for several of Trump’s personal legal problems over the last eight years, beginning in his first term.

The special counsel investigating a possible conspiracy between Russia and the Trump 2016 campaign referred a spinoff investigation of Trump’s then-personal lawyer and fixer, Michael Cohen, to the Southern District. Part of that investigation related to Cohen’s payment to a porn actor, Stormy Daniels, to stop her from going public with a claim of a past affair with Trump while he was the Republican nominee in 2016.

Cohen pleaded guilty to campaign finance violations for those payments, which he said was at the direction of Trump. That paved the way for Trump’s own criminal conviction in 2024, in a prosecution brought by Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg.

The Southern District also indicted Jeffrey Epstein, the sex trafficker who counted Trump, Bill Clinton, Bill Gates, former Obama White House counsel Kathy Ruemmler and others among his contacts. Epstein died in jail before his trial. His longtime co-conspirator, Ghislaine Maxwell, was convicted of sex trafficking in the Southern District in 2021 and sentenced to 20 years in prison.

In the US attorney’s office, which is based in Manhattan, McDonald was a well-regarded assistant US attorney and a member of the team that prosecuted Sheldon Silver, the once powerful Democratic speaker of the New York State Assembly who was convicted in 2015 on corruption charges. (The conviction was overturned on appeal, and Silver was retried and again convicted, and sentenced to seven years in prison. He died in 2022.)

Unlike Clayton, who served in Trump’s first term as chair of the Securities and Exchange Commission and made appearances on CNBC before and during his tenure as US attorney, McDonald has kept a much lower profile.

“He has a rare combination of super high IQ and EQ,” Steven R. Peikin, a friend, partner at Sullivan & Cromwell and fellow Southern District alumnus, said on June 13. He said McDonald would be “a terrific leader” of the Southern District, where he would oversee about 200 assistant US attorneys handling criminal and civil cases.

The acting attorney-general, Todd Blanche, another former Trump personal lawyer who also once worked in the Southern District, described McDonald as “my friend” in a congratulatory post on social media.

During his time at Sullivan & Cromwell, McDonald represented two corporate clients – Live Nation, the music concert promoter, and Polymarket, the prediction market – that received favourable treatment from the Justice Department under Trump.

In March, the department’s antitrust division settled claims against Live Nation, one week into a high-profile trial that examined competition in the music industry.

And in July 2025, federal prosecutors in Manhattan closed a criminal investigation into Polymarket that arose from allegations of wrongdoing stemming from online wagers on elections.

Before clerking for Roberts, McDonald spent a year working in the White House Counsel’s Office under President George W. Bush. He is a graduate of Harvard and the University of Virginia Law School.

Nicholas Biase, a Southern District spokesman, said in a statement that McDonald is “widely respected”, and that “the office welcomes the president’s choice to lead the SDNY”. NYTIMES

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.