Warranty denied over ‘scratches’, Samsung told to fix Z Flip 4 phone or pay Rs 1.1 lakh

5 min readNew DelhiJun 22, 2026 10:27 AM IST

The company argued that the phone’s handset was submitted with Samsung Care after over 11 months of purchase and that it was damaged due to the customer’s negligence. (AI-generated image)

A Punjab consumer commission has held Samsung India liable for deficiency in service and directed it to repair a Z Flip 4 smartphone within one month or refund its price of Rs 90,000 with interest, besides paying Rs 20,000 as compensation, after the company refused to honour the warranty over alleged scratches and physical damage.

A bench of president Kulwinder Singh Pannu and member Rachna Arora were hearing a complaint filed by Hrithik Kanotra, who sought a refund of Rs 90,000 and Rs 1 lakh compensation for mental and physical harassment.

“Therefore, the present complaint of the complainant is Partly Allowed and the OP No. 1 and 2 are directed to repair the disputed mobile handset within one month from the date of receiving the certified copy of this order as the disputed mobile handset is well within the warranty period, failing which the OP No. 1 and 2 are directed to refund the actual price of the disputed mobile handset i.e. Rs 90,000/- along with interest @ 5% per annum from the date of filing of the present complaint till its actual realization,” the June 10 order read.

Company deficient on its part: Court

The consumer body held that Samsung and its authorised service centre were deficient in service for refusing to repair the handset despite it being within the warranty period.

The commission partly allowed the complaint and directed Samsung and the service centre to repair the phone within one month.

If they fail to do so, they must refund Rs 90,000 with 5 per cent annual interest from the date of filing of the complaint until payment.

The commission also directed Samsung and the service centre to pay Rs 20,000 towards mental agony and physical harassment suffered by the complainant.

4 years of litigation

The case of the complainant is that on August 30, 2022, he purchased a Samsung Z Flip 4 mobile phone for Rs 90,000 from a store called The Mobile Zone.

On August 5, 2023, the said phone started facing problems with its sensor and speaker.

Accordingly, on the same day, the complainant had submitted it to the store for repair under warranty. After conducting a full inspection of the phone, they issued a “service request sheet/job sheet”.

As per Samsung policy, the company provides a warranty to every customer for one year from the date of purchase of the mobile phone.

It was further pleaded that on August 8, 2023, the complainant received a phone call from the company stating that the phone was not eligible for repair under warranty because there were many scratches and physical damages on the phone and that they did not consider the product with scratches to be under warranty.

The complainant approached the company directly to avail of his phone warranty on its toll-free number and email ID, but the service care centre also refused to repair the complainant’s phone under warranty.

It was argued by the complainant that the company and service care had dishonest intentions towards providing the phone warranty, as he had allegedly submitted the phone in a pristine condition in service care, having just sensor and speaker problems in it.

Needlessly impleaded as party: Samsung

The company argued that the complaint merits dismissal, pointing out that they have unnecessarily been impleaded as a party. They also stated that no cause of action arose for the complainant to file the complaint against the company.

It was argued that the complainant mishandled and negligently used the mobile phone due to which the handset got physically damaged. The handset was submitted to Samsung Care after over 11 months of purchase and extensive usage. The problem reported by the complainant was ‘LCD Blink’ and ‘unable to open properly’.

It was added that, as per warranty terms and conditions, the handset is out of warranty as it has been physically damaged. It was further pleaded that the complainant has not set out any legitimate ground entitling him to replacement of the mobile phone with damages and litigation costs.

The company argued that it was the complainant’s legal duty to establish his claims that the phone suffered from defects, but no such report has been adduced by the complainant till date.

Story continues below this ad

It was further claimed that the technology used by the company in manufacturing world-class electronic products was highly sophisticated. Thus, no question of any deficiency in service on the part of the answering company arises.

Samsung was represented by advocate Sourabh Ohri in the matter.

Significance of ruling

This ruling underscores that manufacturers cannot refuse warranty obligations without sufficient justification. If a product develops defects during the warranty period, the company must either rectify it or compensate the consumer appropriately.

For consumer-related grievances, individuals may contact the National Consumer Helpline at 1915 or 1800-11-4000 for assistance.

Richa Sahay is a Legal Correspondent for The Indian Express, where she focuses on simplifying the complexities of the Indian judicial system. A law postgraduate, she leverages her advanced legal education to bridge the gap between technical court rulings and public understanding, ensuring that readers stay informed about the rapidly evolving legal landscape.

Expertise

Advanced Legal Education: As a law postgraduate, Richa possesses the academic depth required to interpret intricate statutes and constitutional nuances. Her background allows her to provide more than just summaries; she offers context-driven analysis of how legal changes impact the average citizen.

Specialized Beat: She operates at the intersection of law and public policy, focusing on:

Judicial Updates: Providing timely reports on orders from the Supreme Court of India and various High Courts.

Legal Simplification: Translating dense "legalese" into accessible, engaging narratives without sacrificing factual accuracy.

Legislative Changes: Monitoring new bills, amendments, and regulatory shifts that shape Indian society. ... Read More

Tags:

consumer court

Mobile phone

Samsung